Traditional phishing tests, designed to assess employees’ susceptibility to deceptive emails, have come under increasing scrutiny questioning their effectiveness and potential unintended consequences. A University of Switzerland comprehensive 15-month study involving over 14,000 participants revealed that such tests might inadvertently increase employee clicks rather than reduce their click rates.
Echoing these concerns, Google’s Matt Linton compared early 20th-century fire drills—which often caused more harm than good—to modern phishing tests in this blog post. He argued that these tests focus on individual performance, potentially leading to negative outcomes without significantly enhancing overall security.
These insights suggest that traditional phishing tests may not only be ineffective but could also undermine organizational security efforts and in many reports harm the good will and morale of the companies and individuals being tested. In response, innovative solutions like CyberHoot’s HootPhish offer a more constructive approach, emphasizing education and positive reinforcement to foster a security-conscious culture.
Let’s take a closer look at the traditional challenges fake email phishing contains and some of the benefits of pivoting to a more positive realistic and educational approach that leverages positive reinforcement theory on phish testing simulations.
Enter CyberHoot’s HootPhish—a refreshing alternative that addresses these criticisms head-on. Here’s how HootPhish stands out:
In summary, while traditional phishing tests have been criticized for their inefficacy and negative impact on employees, CyberHoot’s HootPhish offers a promising alternative. By providing better metrics, automation, a positive user experience, effective training outcomes, and improved employee morale, HootPhish not only addresses the shortcomings of conventional methods but also enhances the overall cybersecurity posture of organizations.
CyberHoot’s 6 videos and positive phishing simulation are free for individuals. Enroll here.
Direct Businesses:
Organizations without an MSP or MSSP can use our positive phish testing solution. To empower your team, enroll here.
Enroll your MSP/MSSP in our free 30-day trial with free powerups for life here: Thrive in 25′ Registration Link
Discover and share the latest cybersecurity trends, tips and best practices – alongside new threats to watch out for.
Ever had your phone suddenly lose service for no reason, followed by a flood of “reset your password”...
Read moreAs smart homes get smarter, so do their habits of watching, sensing, and reporting. Enter WiFi Motion Detection, a...
Read moreSpoiler alert: If you’re still using “password123” or “iloveyou” for your login… it’s time for an...
Read moreGet sharper eyes on human risks, with the positive approach that beats traditional phish testing.